Discuss about "place of martyrs immediately after martyrdom and before resurrection" is part of the concern of the researchers, such as: speakers, commentators and orientalists, and of this matter especially has led to the creating of these works in the field. "Vim Rion" (Contemporary orientalist) comments of take pose and analyzed done is in the article the to which have been published under the title "Martyr" in the context of Encyclopedia of the Qur'an, community state or the place of the martyrs. This article, ‌"place of martyrs immediately after martyrdom and before resurrection"‌ is a review in the context of entire the Quran and the authentic hadith and provides a view of its document; then, two of perspective "Rion" would studied in this issue that has a basis of reliability of is, and so from check it out correctness citation it , and with one of the main on selected comments of ten, analyzed content by done in finally, a third criticized in perspective that "Rion" accepted it , and on the admissibility of the team that knows it "Tair" is set. With these valid criticisms of the method of reason, of transport and of history, it is concluded that the admissibility of the foregoing, the reasons to have been from community problem reincarnation, its violation of the admissibility of evidence that the object instance is inconsistent with relative standing and dignity should be, and not of the to the due to the works of deviation of different beliefs of the community, this theory is fake and artificial.

Keywords: hadith of Tair, transition paradise, place of martyr, Vim Rion